Wind turbine drivetrain technology and cost drivers. How it can improve reliability of wind turbine gearboxes novemberdecember 20. Failures are still relatively rare these days because our fleet is recent, but we expect this will change dramatically as our wind turbines approach. In 2006, the german allianz reportedly received 1,000 wind turbine damage claims. Overload and failure of wind turbine gearbox bearings a. Bearing failures and gear tooth failures due to breakage, macropitting and scuffing. What are the differences between turbine which have gear. The failure of the bearings located within the gearbox is the most significant problem associated with the turbines this year, siemens, a main manufacturer of wind turbines, reported a charge of 48 million euros for inspecting and replacing defective main bearings in some onshore wind turbines. High bearing failures have been observed in modern wt gearboxes. Axial cracks that form on the bearings during high and intermediatespeed stages are the leading cause for bearing failures and are the focus of a joint research effort by nrel and argonne national laboratory to identify the root causes and develop mitigation. Some multimegawatt wind turbines have dispensed with a gearbox. A wind turbine gearbox plays a role in multiplying the wind turbine s speed by dozens and transmitting it to the power generator.
Why wind turbines need those troublesome gearboxes youtube. Most gearbox failures do not begin as gear failures or geartooth design deficiencies. Such failure occurs in the high speed rear gearing portion of the gearbox when the bearings become faulty. Wind turbine gearbox condition monitoring round robin. These failures are occurring in spite of the fact that most gearboxes. Technical premature bearing failures in wind gearboxes and. A wind turbine is made up of a number of key parts, and a data source provides failure. A week after andys return, he was approached by windflow technology to design and build the torque limiting gearbox at the heart of the wtl 500 wind turbine.
Common causes of gearbox failure are often related to under designed bearings, bearing misalignment and lubrication issues for both main bearing to gearbox bearings. One alternative to using gearboxes, however, is to use a larger generator with permanent magnets. It is safe to claim that gearbox failures in wind power are considered as a large cost consumer. A wide variety of wind turbine gearbox options are available to you. Gearbox failures are one of the largest sources of unplanned maintenance costs in the wind industry. The following are excerpts from email conversations between. Pdf the feasibility of monitoring the health of wind turbine wt gearboxes based on the lubricant pressure data in the supervisory control.
Shuangwen shawn sheng national renewable energy laboratory mark mcdade national renewable energy laboratory robert errichello geartech. This is the major source for the shaft failure of the turbines. Parts and its functions of wind turbine free download as powerpoint presentation. Wind turbine gearbox failure avoided remote monitoring service prevents gearbox intermediate shaft bearing failure this case study demonstrates how azima dlis remote monitoring services saved a wind turbine gearbox from catastrophic failure. Parts and its functions of wind turbine gear wind turbine.
Wind turbine gearboxes from hansen, bosch, winergy, moventas and other wind turbine gearbox manufactureres for various wind turbine brands like vestas, nordex and neg micon. Advanced signal processing techniques for wind turbine gearbox bearing failure detection conference paper pdf available april 2017 with 237 reads how we measure reads. Manufacturers have made their turbines more reliable by. The gearbox is one of the most expensive components in a wind turbine system, and although failure rates are low compared with some other components, the downtime associated with each failure is significant, as are the repair costs. Overload and failure of wind turbine gearbox bearings bssm. According to recent research keller et al, 2012, gearbox failures happen more frequently as a result of. Sparse feature identification based on union of redundant dictionary for wind turbine gearbox fault diagnosis. Pdf wind turbine gearbox failure identification with.
Two related concepts would make the nacelle of a horizontalaxis wind turbine considerably lighter and smaller, by removing the gear transmission and generator to a location on the main support and near ground level. Department of energy, the national renewable energy laboratory nrel started a gearbox reliability data collection effort under the gearbox reliability collaborative to categorize top wind turbine gearbox failure modes, identify possible root causes, and direct future research and development activities to prevent. According to the latest statistics from the database, the majority of wind turbine gearbox failures 76% are caused by the bearings. Wind turbine gearboxes have been the source of a significant proportion of failures. In the context of wind turbine drivetrains, it is of high relevance to study the planetary stage bearings due to the recurrent failures that. If the tip of the blades is faster than the speed of sound the stresses induced from the shockwaves will destroy the blade and your turbine soon after. Fatigue analysis of wind turbine gearbox bearings using. Unpredictable failure of certain wind turbine components, such as turbine blades, tower, gearbox, generator, braking system, and yaw system, can lead to substantially higher maintenance costs and reduced.
Portsmouthgearboxfailureinvestigation 14october2012. Premature bearing failures in wind gearboxes and white etching cracks kenred stadler and arno stubenrauch wind turbine gearboxes are subjected to a wide variety of operating conditions, some of which may push the bearings beyond their limits. National renewable energy laboratory national wind technology center. Wind turbine gearboxes wind turbines are machines that generate electricity from the power of the wind. The mean downtime for failure was in the range of 615 days for studied landbased european wind turbines over a year time period with a failure rate of 0.
The one megawatt wind turbine is a unique approach to converting wind to electrical power. Standard solutions for wind turbine gearbox lubrication oil filtration and cooling systems turbine gearbox power main specification for lubricating and cooling system electrically driven pump mechanically driven pump integrated filter functions cooler as examples oil reservoir as part of gearbox casting oil reservoir as separate tank. Fixing windturbine gearbox problems machine design. A survey of failures in wind turbine generator systems. Despite great efforts to improve the wind turbine gearbox designs, analysis, manufacturing, lubrication systems, control systems, etc. Five common gearbox failures and how to identify them north. In over 20 years of providing expert engineering services to the global vehicle, aerospace, marine, rail and wind energy industries, romax created and refined romax designer, the worlds first object orientated engineering analysis software package. Mar 16, 2016 the ahp method is based on computing the weights of criteria level 2 and alternatives level 3 with respect to the level just above their own level fig. Thus, criterion weights priority are calculated with respect to the goal, and barrier weights are computed with respect to each of the criterion. Use of scada and cms signals for failure detection and diagnosis of a wind turbine gearbox yanhui feng, yingning qiu, christopher j crabtree, hui long, peter j tavner energy group, school of engineering and computing sciences, durham university, uk. Vestas v903mw wind turbine gearbox health assessment using a. One of the most important components of wind turbines are gearboxes. The majority of wind turbine gearbox failures appear to initiate in the bearings.
This paper details the proposal and validation of a potential temperature monitoring technique for use in wind turbine condition monitoring. A survey of failures in wind turbine generator systems with. Depending on the type of the wind turbine generator three or four azimuth gearboxes are applied to turn the tower into the wind. Pdf wind turbine gearbox failure and remaining useful. The gearbox is one of the important subassemblies within supervisory control a wind turbine wt, in respect of downtime. Wind turbine gearboxes power transmission engineering. This product can be said to be our core product, and ishibashi manufacturing is highly valued as a manufacturer of madeinjapan wind turbine gearboxes with the no. The premature failure of gearbox bearings causes unplanned wt shutdowns and early bearing replacements, reducing wt availability and. Apr 01, 2014 repairing or replacing a failed wind turbine gearbox is an extremely expensive undertaking.
Advanced signal processing techniques for wind turbine. Pdf wind turbine gearbox technologies researchgate. Vestas v903mw wind turbine gearbox health assessment. Gearbox typical failure modes, detection and mitigation. Gearbox failures are an issue in the wind industry, but oems are using new approaches for testing, manufacturing, design, and operations to improve turbine. Andy ignored the experts advice and took up the challenge. Technical premature bearing failures in wind gearboxes. Overload and failure of wind turbine gearbox bearings. While the main gearbox transformes the relatively low rotor revolution speed into a higher revolution speed required by the generator, the pitch and azimuth gearboxes help to optimize the use of the wind power. Standard solutions for wind turbine gearbox lubrication oil filtration and cooling systems turbine gearbox power main specification for lubricating and cooling system electrically driven pump mechanically driven pump integrated filter functions cooler as examples oil. Effects of bearing configuration in wind turbine gearbox reliability. Five common gearbox failures and how to identify them. This product can be said to be our core product, and ishibashi manufacturing is highly valued as a manufacturer of madeinjapan windturbine gearboxes with the no.
Design of wind turbine gearboxes with respect to noise. Pdf this paper presents a reliability analysis model of wind turbine gearboxes by developing a generic gearbox configuration and modular structure. Dynamic analysis of wind turbine gearbox components mdpi. An important part of any maintenance program is to understand the root cause of failures and how to identify them.
Pdf reliability analysis and prediction of wind turbine gearboxes. Gearbox typical failure modes, detection and mitigation methods. The main components include the gearbox, generator and power electronic converters. Rather, failures tend to stem from several specific bearing locations under. The turbine blades themselves, however, cant turn very fast because they wouldnt be able to take the centrifugal strain. Amtech international amtech, oem supplier of gears, castings, shafts and forgings. Gearbox failures are an issue in the wind industry, but oems are using new approaches for testing, manufacturing, design, and operations to. Reliability analysis and prediction of wind turbine gearboxes. If the velocity of the wind exceeds the prescribed limit then the failure takes place. However, there are other gear arrangements in which the shaft s are not parallel. The operating speed of a turbine is limited by the size of the largest turbine compressor blade.
The course was run by robert errichello, one of the worlds leading experts in gear failure analysis. During the period of quick introduction rate, failures during wind turbines operation were common. Figure 1 depicts the size of the quantum drive gearbox of a liberty 2. Marshall1 dynamics1 research group, department ofmechanical engineering, the university sheffield, mappin. Gear types based on gear axes in the aforementioned gear arrangement, the axes of the two shaft s onto which gears are mounted are parallel to each other.
A windturbine gearbox plays a role in multiplying the wind turbines speed by dozens and transmitting it to the power generator. Ran bi et al a survey of failures in wind turbine generator systems with focus on a wind farm in china. Failure rates of the critical components are estimated by. How it can improve reliability of wind turbine gearboxes novemberdecember 20 historically, wind turbine gearbox failures have plagued the industry. The mean downtime for failure was in the range of 615 days for. The intent of this standard is to describe the differences.
The system uses both a downwind main rotor and a counter rotating, higher speed, upwind auxiliary rotor driving a very unique 1200 hp gearbox. Marshall1 dynamics1 research group, department ofmechanical engineering, the university sheffield, mappin street, sheffield, s1 3jd, uk 2leonardo centre for tribology, department ofmechanical engineering, the university sheffield, mappin. Pdf wind turbine gearbox failure identification with deep. Read more or visit lafert north america your best source for metric motors, gearboxes and coolant pumps, by providing quality products with the highest level of service in the industry. This chapter describes the wind turbine drive train systems. This standard is a tool whereby wind turbine and gearbox manufacturers can communicate and understand each others needs. During the course mr errichello explained the gearbox issues involved in the wind industry and recommended that anyone invited to get involved in that aspect of the gear industry should. Most wind turbines have gearbox transmissions that connect the slowly spinning turbine with the speedhungry generator. A large turbine rotates slowly and a small turbine has a higher rotating speed even if the bladetip speed is the same. Cooling systems are used to reduce losses and wear due to overheating since maintenance due to fatigue or failure is a loss of availability.
Lubrication oil filtration systems for wind turbine gearboxes. Gearboxes need regular maintenance and lubrication, increasing their total cost of ownership. Damage may be done to the bearings, resulting in a specific premature failure mode. Geartech, gear failure analysis a textbook for the gear failure analyst. This case study demonstrates how azima dlis remote monitoring services saved a wind turbine gearbox from catastrophic failure. Wikov designs, manufactures, supplies and services a wide range of standardized series of planetary gearboxes orbiflex and helical gear units standard for small hydro power plants. Zf wind power 21 design of wind turbine gearboxes with respect to noise 11122012 status zf gearbox gearbox simulation models ready 1st proto gearbox test rig measurements done gearbox assembly in wind turbine planned outlook planned for 20 additional test rig measurements. Regular turbine realignments can reduce the frequency of failure, but do not preclude their occurrence.
Some time ago, andy horsfall from ah gears in auckland attended a gear failure analysis course in montana. The main function of a drive train is power transmission, i. Pdf wind turbine gearbox failure identification with deep neural. Wind turbine gearbox failure identification with deep neural networks article pdf available in ieee transactions on industrial informatics pp99. A gearbox is typically used in a wind turbine to increase rotational speed from a lowspeed rotor to a higher speed electrical generator. Hydro power highlyefficient customized gearboxes for small hydro power plants. Reliability block diagrams of gearbox modules and components have been established by using relex reliability analysis software. Pdf this research investigates the prediction of failure and remaining useful life rul of gearboxes for modern multi. Wind turbine gearbox failure avoided plant services. This standard is a tool whereby wind turbine and gearbox manufacturers. It encapsulates all the reliability critical components within the gearbox subsystem in a wind turbine. So a gear box is needed to step up the slow turbine motion rotations to the faster generator rotations. Wind turbine gearbox reliability database, condition.
676 648 393 236 651 402 846 127 1169 401 1448 1090 649 269 167 1400 927 759 856 953 976 90 849 1347 1471 1463 1320 1495 1432 1274 426 154 314 1123 151 464 581 363 1184 1177 1176 106 264 782 1487 802 345 492 80